In early September 1654, a group of 23 Jewish refugees arrived in New Amsterdam — the Dutch settlement that became New York City — aboard the French privateer St. Catherine, after fleeing Recife, Brazil, when the Portuguese recaptured it from the Dutch. Governor Peter Stuyvesant tried to expel them, but the Dutch West India Company overruled him in April 1655 and allowed Jews to live, trade, and travel in the colony. The group founded the first permanent Jewish settlement in North America and, soon after, Congregation Shearith Israel, the oldest Jewish congregation in the United States.
History
The 23 refugees — Sephardic and some Ashkenazi Jews, including families with children — had left Recife after the Portuguese recaptured Dutch Brazil in January 1654 and Jews were ordered to leave within three months rather than face the Inquisition. Their ship was waylaid in the Caribbean and they were taken aboard the French privateer St. Catherine, which carried them to New Amsterdam, where they disembarked in early September 1654; a town record of September 7 documents their arrival. Director-General Peter Stuyvesant, who objected to settlers outside the Dutch Reformed Church, wrote to the Dutch West India Company on September 22, 1654, asking that the Jews be made to leave. Jewish shareholders in Amsterdam petitioned the company on the refugees’ behalf, and on April 26, 1655, the company ordered Stuyvesant to let the Jews remain, ‘provided the poor among them shall not become a burden to the company or to the community.’ Burgher rights — the right to conduct retail and wholesale trade — were extended to Jews in 1657, and the right to own property was upheld. The community they founded became Congregation Shearith Israel, which remains the oldest Jewish congregation in the United States.
Why it matters
The arrival of the 23 in 1654 is the founding event of Jewish life in New York and in North America: every later wave of Jewish immigration built on the community they started. The Dutch West India Company’s ruling established an early precedent that Jews could live, trade, and travel in the colony on the same terms as other settlers, provided they supported their own poor. In September 2024, the New York City Council voted to officially recognize Landing Day, celebrated during the second week of September, to mark the arrival.
Key facts
- When did the first Jews arrive in New York? In early September 1654; a New Amsterdam town record dated September 7, 1654 documents their arrival.
- How many settlers were there? 23 Jewish men, women, and children — described in the records as four couples, two widows, and thirteen children.
- Why did they leave Recife? Portugal recaptured Recife from the Dutch in January 1654, and Jews were ordered to leave Brazil within three months rather than face the Portuguese Inquisition.
- What ship brought them to New Amsterdam? The French privateer St. Catherine (also spelled Sainte Catherine or St. Charles in different sources), captained by Jacques de la Motthe.
- How did the Dutch West India Company rule? In a letter dated April 26, 1655, the company rejected Stuyvesant’s request to expel the Jews and ordered that they ‘may travel and trade to and in New Netherland and live and remain there, provided the poor among them shall not become a burden to the company or to the community.’
Sources checked November 16, 2026
- Jewish Virtual Library — New York City (Encyclopaedia Judaica)
- Jewish Virtual Library — New York State Jewish History
- My Jewish Learning — Jewish New York: The Early Years
- Jewish Virtual Library — Recife, Brazil
- Wikipedia — Jews in New Amsterdam (for the April 26, 1655 letter date)
Recommend the Best
Had a helpful experience with First Jewish Settlers in New York, 1654 — Jewish History of New York? Tell us what stood out and who could benefit.
Selected recommendations are an editorial selection, not a complete collection of customer reviews or a ranking. Submissions are reviewed before publication.
Reviews
No reviews yet — be the first to review

